SEO

Is Checkatrade Worth It? What AI Answers Showed Shropshire Tradespeople

Illustration of a teal house beside a black wrench and a round badge with a star, with a chat bubble containing a sparkle

Checkatrade can be worth it, but it is no substitute for your own website and Google Business Profile. When we asked ChatGPT and Gemini to recommend a plumber in seven Shropshire towns, Checkatrade was a source in 10 of the 14 answers. The plumbers' own websites supplied just 4 of the 49 recommendations. That shows how much reach the platform has, and how little the assistants took from tradespeople's own sites.

This article looks at what Checkatrade costs in November 2026, what changed when Checkatrade Group took over Rated People's brand, how MyBuilder and others charge, and what our research on 9 November 2026 says about where plumbers and electricians are found today.

In short

  • Cost: Checkatrade has no joining fee. Its cheapest listing starts from £30 + VAT a month but sends no leads. Lead plans are priced by trade and area and run for 12 months.
  • Rated People: it is now part of Checkatrade Group. Its memberships were closed and its leads now go to Checkatrade members.
  • AI answers: Checkatrade was cited in 10 of 14 answers about plumbers. Plumbers' own websites were cited for 8% of recommendations, electricians' for 23%.
  • Trade websites: plumbers' sites beat the local average on titles and contact details. They fall behind on postcodes and local business markup.
  • Our view: use a platform for leads you can afford, but build reviews and visibility on assets you own.

What does Checkatrade cost in 2026?

Checkatrade does not publish a single price list, because pricing depends on your trade, your area and how many leads you want. These are the points it states itself:

  • No joining fee. Checkatrade's guide to its costs says members pay a monthly fee only, and that VAT is charged on it.
  • A basic listing from £30 + VAT a month. The same guide says this lets customers find you by searching your name, but it does not provide sales leads.
  • A fixed lead plan, priced by trade and area. Checkatrade sends matched leads through the year. According to Checkatrade's notice on the Rated People sign-up page, its sales team quotes the price and the plan runs on a 12-month term.
  • An Opportunities Board. A free account where you browse local jobs and pay only for the leads you choose to unlock.

Checkatrade's pay-as-you-go product terms add detail on lead pricing. The fee per lead varies with job value, channel, location, season and demand. You set a monthly budget, and you can be charged up to 120% of it in a month. Checkatrade may ask for a deposit of up to twice that budget. A "lead" can be a call, a message, a quote request or a click through to your website. The terms also say the number of leads you receive depends partly on how many reviews you get and how complete your profile is.

Membership also includes Checkatrade's guarantee for jobs up to £1,000 booked through the platform, subject to its terms. Many blogs quote typical monthly costs, but most are written by competing platforms, so we do not repeat their figures. Before you sign, ask for a written quote that shows the total cost over the full 12 months.

What happened to Rated People?

In September 2026, Checkatrade Group bought selected assets of Rated People. Its law firm announced the deal on 24 September 2026. Rated People's trade sign-up page now says that:

  • Rated People is part of Checkatrade Group, and jobs posted on it are routed to Checkatrade tradespeople;
  • Rated People closed all memberships before the takeover;
  • leads in old Rated People accounts are no longer accessible there;
  • existing Rated People reviews "stay where they are".

So "Checkatrade vs Rated People" is no longer a choice. If Rated People was a source of work for you, the only way to keep receiving those jobs is to join Checkatrade.

The reviews point matters more than it looks. Reviews you collected on a platform belong to that platform's account, and when the account closed, they stayed behind. Reviews on your own Google Business Profile move with your business.

How do MyBuilder, Yell and Bark charge?

The other platforms that tradespeople ask about work in different ways:

PlatformHow you payPlumber answers citing itElectrician answers citing it
CheckatradeMonthly listing, 12-month lead plan or pay per unlocked lead10 of 141 of 14
MyBuilderA non-refundable shortlist fee each time a customer shortlists you5 of 142 of 14
YellA business directory that also sells managed marketing3 of 142 of 14
BarkCredits spent to contact customers0 of 140 of 14
Rated PeopleNow routed to Checkatrade0 of 140 of 14

Under MyBuilder's trade terms (February 2024 version), the shortlist fee is shown before you express interest in a job and depends on the job's likely size, value and location. MyBuilder cannot guarantee that a shortlist leads to work. The terms also forbid swapping contact details outside the platform, including sending a customer to your own website, to avoid the fee. Bark's help centre explains its credits and credit pack subscriptions. Yell Business sells managed advertising alongside its directory.

Where do AI assistants find plumbers and electricians?

Chart titled: Where AI answers about tradespeople came from. 14 answers each for plumbers and electricians, ChatGPT and Gemini, seven Shropshire towns, 9 November 2026. Answers citing each source, plumbers then electricians: Checkatrade 10 and 1; MyBuilder 5 and 2; Yell 3 and 2; TopRatedElectricians 0 and 2; local directories and town guides 0 and 3; other listings such as Cylex and TrustATrader 2 and 1; NICEIC register 0 and 1. Recommendations cited from the tradesperson's own website: plumbers 4 of 49, 8%; electricians 10 of 44, 23%. Source: Digiwings research.
Which sources ChatGPT and Gemini cited when asked to recommend a plumber or an electrician in seven Shropshire towns.

On 9 November 2026 we asked ChatGPT and Gemini, signed out and on a UK connection, to recommend a plumber and an electrician in Shrewsbury, Telford, Oswestry, Bridgnorth, Ludlow, Market Drayton and Whitchurch. That gave 14 answers for each trade. The full method is in our article on how businesses get recommended by ChatGPT.

Plumbers. The assistants made 49 recommendations and cited the plumber's own website for 4 of them, 8%. Eleven of the 14 answers drew on at least one platform. Checkatrade was cited in 10, MyBuilder in 5 and Yell in 3. ChatGPT showed star ratings beside the names in 6 of its 7 plumber answers.

Electricians. The picture was more balanced. Ten of the 44 recommendations, 23%, came from the electrician's own website, and only 8 of the 14 answers used a platform. No single platform dominated: Yell, MyBuilder and TopRatedElectricians each appeared twice and Checkatrade once, alongside local directories. In Shrewsbury, both assistants brought up NICEIC or NAPIT registration, the schemes electricians use to show their work is assessed.

Rated People and Bark did not appear as a source in any of the 28 trade answers.

Are tradespeople's websites the problem?

Comparison titled: Trade websites against other local businesses. 54 plumber, 56 electrician and 301 other independent business websites in seven Shropshire towns, checked 9 November 2026. Home-page title names the town or Shropshire: plumbers 69%, electricians 57%, other businesses 50%. Phone number on the home page: 94%, 96%, 86%. Valid HTTPS certificate: 98%, 82%, 95%. Full postcode on the home or contact page: 74%, 75%, 89%. Structured data naming a local business type: 30%, 21%, 24%. Note: many tradespeople work from home and rightly hide their address, so the towns they cover need to be named in the page text instead. Source: Digiwings research.
How the plumber and electrician websites in our sample compare with 301 other local business websites.

Not on the basics. Among the 411 independent Shropshire business websites we checked, 54 belonged to plumbers and 56 to electricians. Plumbers' sites scored better than average on several points: 69% named the town or county in the home-page title, against 50% for other businesses, and 94% showed a phone number on the home page. Electricians were close behind on titles and phone numbers, but only 82% had a valid HTTPS certificate, against 95% for other businesses.

The gaps were elsewhere. Only about three in four trade sites gave a full postcode, against 89% of other businesses. That is often for a good reason: many tradespeople work from home, and Google itself tells service-area businesses to remove an address where they do not serve customers. But it means the website has to name the towns and villages it covers in plain text, or search tools have little to go on. Local business structured data appeared on 30% of plumbers' sites and 21% of electricians'.

Our interpretation, which we did not measure directly: the assistants used platforms for what trade websites rarely show in a form they can quote. That means independent reviews, vetting, the jobs a tradesperson does and the areas they cover. A platform profile carries all four by design. A website can carry them too, if someone writes them down.

So, is Checkatrade worth it?

It depends on where your work comes from now. Based on Checkatrade's own terms and what we saw in AI answers, it is more likely to pay off if:

  • you are new or have few reviews, and need customers to trust you before your reputation builds;
  • you want a steady flow of enquiries now and can respond to them quickly;
  • you are a plumber or in a similar trade where, in our test, the platform dominated AI answers;
  • the vetting badge and the guarantee on jobs booked through the platform matter to your customers.

Think harder before signing a 12-month lead plan if:

  • most of your work already comes from referrals, repeat customers or Google;
  • your typical job is small, so lead fees take a large share of the margin;
  • you cannot be sure of keeping up payments for a full year;
  • your trade, like electricians in our test, is found through a mix of sources rather than one platform.

Either way, treat platform visibility as rented. The reach is real, but the profile, the reviews and the leads sit on someone else's terms, as Rated People's members found out in September. Assets you own keep their value: your website, your Google Business Profile and the reviews on it.

How to win more work without relying on a platform

  1. Write a page for each job you want more of. Boiler servicing, bathroom installation, rewiring, EV charger installation: say what is included, roughly what it costs and how long it takes.
  2. Name the places you cover in plain text. List the towns and villages you actually work in on your service pages, especially if your address is hidden.
  3. Show your registrations properly. Gas Safe, NICEIC or NAPIT membership should appear as text with your registration number and a link to the public register, not only as a logo.
  4. Set up your Google Business Profile as a service-area business. Choose service areas by town or postcode, pick accurate categories and add photos of real jobs.
  5. Collect Google reviews after every job. Ask while the customer is pleased, and reply to every review. Never buy or script them: fake reviews have been unlawful in the UK since April 2025.
  6. Show reviews on your site honestly. Quote them with their source. Do not add star markup to reviews of your own business: Google's review snippet guidelines only allow local business ratings on sites that review other businesses.
  7. Keep your details identical everywhere, including on any platform profile you keep.
  8. Ask the assistants yourself once a month. Ask for your trade in your town, note which sources appear and fix the ones that describe you badly.

What this means for Shropshire trades

Checkatrade appeared in plumber answers for six of the seven towns we tested: Shrewsbury, Telford, Oswestry, Bridgnorth, Ludlow and Market Drayton. In Whitchurch, ChatGPT asked which Whitchurch we meant before naming anyone, a different problem that we cover on our Whitchurch SEO page. For a Shropshire plumber, that makes the platform hard to ignore. It also means a plumber with a strong website and Google profile stands out, because so few were cited from their own sites.

Each town's full results are on its local page, for example SEO in Shrewsbury, SEO in Telford and SEO in Oswestry.

How can Digiwings help?

We build websites and run local SEO for Shropshire businesses from our studio in Shrewsbury. If you want to know whether your website, your Google profile or a platform is bringing in your work, send us your website and we will check how ChatGPT, Gemini and Google show your trade in your area, free of charge. You can also see our web design packages and local SEO retainers.

Frequently asked questions

Is Checkatrade worth it for tradesmen?

It can be, especially for a newer business that needs leads and reviews quickly. In our Shropshire test, Checkatrade was cited in 10 of 14 AI answers about plumbers. But lead plans run for 12 months and the reviews stay on the platform, so build your own website and Google reviews at the same time.

How much does Checkatrade cost per month?

Checkatrade says there is no joining fee and its basic listing starts from £30 + VAT a month, without sales leads. Lead plans are priced by trade and area and run on a 12-month term. Its Opportunities Board is free to join, and you pay only for the leads you unlock.

Is Checkatrade worth it for electricians?

The case is weaker than for plumbers in our data. Checkatrade appeared in only 1 of 14 AI answers about electricians, and 23% of recommended electricians were cited from their own websites. Assistants also raised NICEIC and NAPIT registration, so a clear website that shows yours is worth more than usual.

What happened to Rated People?

Checkatrade Group bought selected assets of Rated People in September 2026. Rated People's site says its memberships were closed and that jobs posted there are now routed to Checkatrade tradespeople. Existing Rated People reviews stay where they are.

What is the difference between Checkatrade and MyBuilder?

Checkatrade sells a monthly listing, a 12-month lead plan or pay-per-lead access. MyBuilder charges a non-refundable shortlist fee each time a customer shortlists you, based on the job's size, value and location. In our test, MyBuilder appeared in 5 of 14 plumber answers and Checkatrade in 10.

Do I still need a website if I am on Checkatrade?

Yes. A platform profile can close or change terms, as Rated People members found in 2026. Your own website and Google Business Profile are the assets you keep, and an assistant can only quote your own site if it gives specific details about your jobs, areas and registrations.

Sources

Our own data was collected on 9 November 2026. Platform pages and terms were checked on 10 November 2026; prices and terms can change, so check them again before you sign anything.

Illustration and charts: Digiwings.